Your nickel is stuck in 1982: New York's 5-cent deposit compared with a 10-cent modern Bottle Bill, with the Can Bottle Return logo.

In 1982, a gallon of gas cost about $1.30, a movie ticket was under $3, and New York put a 5-cent deposit on cans and bottles. Gas and movie tickets have gone up a lot since then. The deposit is still a nickel.

New York’s Bottle Bill is one of the most successful environmental laws the state has ever passed. It keeps billions of containers out of landfills, off roadsides and out of our lakes and streams every year. But a law built for 1982 is now running a 2026 system, and the cracks are showing in our neighborhoods, our fundraisers and our wallets.

At Can Bottle Return, we see it every day. Here’s what’s happening, and what a modern, expanded and transparent Bottle Bill would fix.

The redemption centers you rely on are disappearing

Redemption centers are paid a handling fee to sort, count and process every container you bring in. That fee has been 3.5 cents since 2009. Over the same years, wages, fuel, insurance, equipment and rent have all risen sharply.

Imagine running any business on 2009 prices forever. That’s what the law asks of redemption centers, and many can’t keep going. More than 150 redemption centers have closed across New York, including 43 in Western New York.

When your neighborhood redemption center closes, you still pay the deposit at the register. You just have fewer places to get it back. Every nickel that isn’t redeemed stays with the state. For families who count on those returns, that works like a tax nobody voted for.

Bottle drives fund our communities

Can and bottle drives are among the most common and reliable fundraisers in New York. Schools, youth sports teams, scout troops, churches, veterans’ groups, animal rescues and charities all depend on them.

Here in Western New York, Can Bottle Return has helped local organizations raise hundreds of thousands of dollars through bottle drives and drop-off donations. Across the state, container donations have raised millions.

A modern Bottle Bill would put that fundraising into overdrive:

It’s about your bottom line too

When redemption centers close and containers go uncovered, everyone pays. Residents lose access to money they’ve already paid. Towns and cities pay to haul and process bottles and cans that end up in curbside bins or as litter. An independent study estimated that modernizing the Bottle Bill could save New York municipalities $40 million to $109 million a year in recycling and waste costs. That’s money that stays in local budgets.

States that have updated their laws are seeing results. Michigan’s 10-cent deposit gets about 89% of containers returned. New York’s return rate is around 68%.

Transparency: where does the money go?

Every year, New York keeps about $118 million in unclaimed deposits. Yet there’s no complete annual public report showing how many containers come back, where the unclaimed money goes, or where fraud is happening.

A modern Bottle Bill would require yearly public reporting from the Department of Environmental Conservation, published lists of registered redemption centers, and a coordinated effort to stop fraud. Taxpayers, retailers, distributors and redemption centers all deserve to see the numbers.

What a modern Bottle Bill does

The proposal before the Legislature, S5684 (Sen. Rachel May) / A6543 (Asm. Deborah Glick), would:

  1. Modernize the deposit to 10 cents and raise the handling fee so redemption centers can stay open.
  2. Expand coverage to non-carbonated drinks like water, juice, tea and sports drinks, plus hard cider.
  3. Bring transparency through annual public reporting and stronger fraud prevention.
Infographic: Why New York needs a modern Bottle Bill. The deposit has not changed since 1982, 150+ redemption centers have closed, and the state keeps $118 million in unclaimed deposits each year.

More than 300 business, civic and environmental groups across New York support modernization. Local governments are adding their voices too: the Town of Aurora recently passed a resolution of support.

How you can help

New York’s Bottle Bill has worked for more than four decades. With a few smart updates, it can keep working for the next forty years for our communities, our fundraisers and every family that brings back its empties.

Questions, or want your organization to sign on? Contact Can Bottle Return at (716) 649-2242, visit us at 4255 Clark Street in Hamburg, or follow us at @CBR_Hamburg.